Letter: Councilors’ Resistance To Anti-Racism Training Reflects Unwillingness To Examine Their Own Privilege

Photo: Ms.Magazine. Creative Commons

Many of us have been binging Netflix during the pandemic, but on Monday night, it wasn’t a plot twist in Lupin that made my eyes widen. No, on Monday night my jaw dropped to the floor as I watched multiple members of our elected Town Council state their objection to a two-day racial equity training program, citing a lack of specific outcomes, the time asked of them to engage in this work, and perhaps most alarming, not wanting to sit in a training during “nice weather.”  

There are a few things we know for sure, which were reiterated at Monday’s meeting. Town Council meetings are long. Our Town Councilors serve on multiple committees, draft policy, and do other important work in service to the town that takes a significant amount of their time. Many of the Councilors hold full-time jobs, have families, or would like to have balance between their work on the council and their lives outside of it. We know all of this to be true. 

And what else do we know?

We know that our Town Council is majority white-presenting. We know that the BIPOC (Black, Indiginous, and People of Color) members of our community, and specifically Black members of our community are calling for now (and have been calling for) necessary change. Change including increased effort of the council to examine its own biases, as well as its participation in and perpetuation of systemic and structural racism. We know that the Town of Amherst must no longer willfully ignore the harm done to the BIPOC community, (and as that label represents many identities and is not a monolith of experience), especially Black members of our community. We know that White community members must no longer attend protests like they are activism checklists, returning to the comfort of privilege as soon as they leave the crowd.  We know that change needs to be reflected in our budget, our policy, and our leadership.

Here’s the thing about a two-day racial equity and bias training. It isn’t a checklist, and it isn’t enough. A training like the one proposed by Councilors Bahl-Milne and DeAngelis (who I thank for their effort and words of recommendation) should be a spark for those beginning their journey into interrogating their own privilege and bias, and fuel for the fire in those who are working on doing so already. 

The work around equity, inclusion, and justice is not comparable to any other work the council does or will do, it underlies all of it, informs all of it, and should be prioritized.  It was mentioned in the meeting that asking councilors to attend a two-day training sent a message about the high time commitment of being on council.  To be frank, statements like that send a larger message about the perceived importance of this work. 

Two days is just the start. Two days is not enough. We need to hold this council and future councils to a higher standard of self-awareness around their own power and privilege, and ensure that bridges are being built from their individual learning and unlearning to the work being done on the council. For every decision being made by the council, they must ask how it is advancing equity, inclusion, and justice in our community. What is the outcome of this training or those like it? It is another step in the direction of being an elected body that understands it may not be representative of the community and that its policies are informed by the identities of those writing them. The training could help the council use its knowledge to take action to repair what power and privilege have harmed and to course-correct so that it does not happen again. 

You know when the right time for this retreat to have happened was? Before councilors were sworn in. You know the second best time? As soon as humanly possible…regardless of how nice the weather is. 

Ana Devlin Gauthier

Ana Devlin Gauthier is a resident of District 5 

Spread the love

5 thoughts on “Letter: Councilors’ Resistance To Anti-Racism Training Reflects Unwillingness To Examine Their Own Privilege

  1. Like Ana Devlin-Gauthier, I was astounded Monday night when several Town Councilors voiced their reluctance to participate in anti-racist training. Councilors may have too many meetings, but just what are the Town’s priorities? Densification? Destination Amherst? Roundabouts? Wayfinding? Let’s look at some recent Amherst history.

    Most of my 25 year tenure as an Amherst public school teacher was spent at Mark’s Meadow Elementary School which, for many years, had the most diverse student population in Amherst racially, economically and culturally.

    In 1993, the NAACP sued the Amherst-Pelham Regional Schools for having too few students of color in upper level classes at junior high and high school as “tracking” was then the norm. Students of color were also received more disciplinary actions than white students. As part of the settlement, every teacher in Amherst (K-12) was required to take a rigorous three credit college course on racism.

    I thought the course would be a snap. After all, I was a product of a “Damn Yankee” World War II air pilot and a debutante Southern Belle war bride. Summers at my grandmother’s home in Indianola, Mississippi, including the summer after the Civil Rights Act of 1964, had immersed me in white supremacist culture.

    A short vignette from those days: One Sunday after church, the boys in my teenage crowd boasted of scoring ten points for running over an arm, 20 for a leg of black kids (not the term used) the night before. I was shocked.

    Approaching the course, hadn’t I already learned enough about discrimination and racial hatred? Absolutely not! The required course assignments involved in-person activities in which I would be in the minority as well as weekly papers and extensive readings. The class opened my eyes further and reinvigorated continuing self-reflection ever since.

    So, a two day workshop is just a beginning, yet an important one. Perhaps the Councilors might put this priority first instead of spending hours discussing how to prevent those with diverse views from serving on town committees.

    These councilors should be ashamed.

  2. Thank you, Ana, for this article. I was not able to tune into the meeting this week so thank you for bringing attention to this very troubling discussion.

  3. We need to make sure to remember councilors statements and in this case a lack of action and commitment regarding antiracist work in this town.

  4. Pingback: Amherst Indy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.