Town Council Rejects Data Center Moratorium, Ban Still Under Consideration
Data center complex in Gainesville, Northern Virginia. Photo: Eil Wilson c/o Shutterstock
Report on the Meeting of the Amherst Town Council, Nov. 16, 2026, Part 2
By Maura Keene
This hybrid meeting was held in Town Hall and recorded.
Present
Mandi Jo Hanneke (president, at large), Andy Churchill and Ellisha Walker (at large), Jill Brevik and Cathy Schoen (District 1), Amber Cano-Martin and Lynn Griesemer (District 2), Hala Lord and George Ryan (District 3), Pam Rooney and Jennifer Taub (District 4), Ana Devlin Gauthier and Sam MacLeod (District 5).
Staff: Paul Bockelman (town manager) and Athena O’Keeffe (clerk of council).
Sponsors Withdraw Proposed Data Center Moratorium
Following a public hearing on banning data centers in Amherst that was opened jointly by the Planning Board and Community Resources Committee (CRC), three of the nine sponsors of the proposed ban introduced a proposal for a two-year moratorium on constructing data centers, in order to define which types of facilities would be affected by a ban.
The three sponsors of the moratorium were Councilors Andy Churchill, Lynn Griesemer, and Cathy Schoen. Churchill admitted that no one wants a large data center at Hampshire College or anywhere else in town, but thought a moratorium would buy time for the bylaws being written by the Massachusetts Municipal Association and evolving state-level efforts to guide the town. Churchill wanted to exclude small data centers in colleges, universities, or healthcare facilities from a ban.
However, after realizing that no permits for data centers could be granted while the Planning Board and CRC hearings were open, Churchill decided to withdraw the moratorium proposal. The other two sponsors also agreed to withdraw the proposal. Schoen said she didn’t want the two hearings open at the same time. The Planning Board/CRC hearing has been continued until January 6.
After the three sponsors of the moratorium withdrew their support, Council President Mandi Jo Hanneke asked if there were any other councilors willing to sponsor it. When no one responded, she said, “Because I would like to discuss this motion, I am going to add my name to the sponsorship.”
However, Hanneke was unable to convince her fellow councilors of the need for a moratorium. Following further discussion, the proposal was defeated 1-12 with only Hanneke voting in favor.
Hanneke raised the possibility of indefinitely delaying a hearing on a data center ban and said that crafting a bylaw outside of a hearing was “best practice.” But Churchill was confident that a new bylaw banning data centers was fairly straightforward, and could be developed in a few months.
Jennifer Taub said, “CRC and Planning Board members are working together to expedite the process. We’re looking at what level we would accept a data center, because there seems to be a really stout consensus that we don’t want anything on the order of a hyperscale [center] or anything close to that. So, I think this is the most expeditious way to move forward quickly.”
Sam MacLeod wanted to make sure the bylaw had no loopholes that would allow “some behemoth” to buy a property and try to build a large data center. But he wasn’t convinced that using a moratorium to craft a bylaw would close loopholes.
Jill Brevik said, “I feel like people were pretty clear. The resounding commentary was that they didn’t want us spending a lot of time and town resources deliberating something we’re all pretty clear we don’t want. People came out in numbers to say we don’t want the town spending an exorbitant amount of time on this.”
Pulpit Hill Site to Be Considered for New DPW
The original charge for the DPW Building Committee was to build a new facility at the current site at 561 South Pleasant Street. However, limitations in the site’s size led the committee to investigate the Ruxton site on Pulpit Hill Road as an alternative. Bockelman asked the council to amend the committee charge so that both sites can be evaluated. The motion passed 12-0 with Ellisha Walker absent for the vote.
Bockelman admitted that no site meets all of the DPW requirements, but Ruxton offers several advantages over the South Pleasant Street site. It is larger and would not require the DPW to relocate during construction. Moving the DPW to Ruxton would also enable the fire station to be built at the current DPW site.
Bockelman said the town had evaluated several other sites over the past 10 years, but none were viable. A Belchertown Road site met with opposition from abutters, and other sites would require the town to purchase them at a high cost. This was also true of the residential land abutting the current site, which is valued at over a million dollars.
Councilor George Ryan stated that a major disadvantage of Ruxton is its location at the north end of town. He worried about the increased traffic in and out of the site and the distance vehicles would have to travel to provide service. The proposed change in the charge would not mean that Ruxton is the chosen site, only that the building committee could consider it. Ryan recognized the need to reach out to the North Amherst community.
Griesemer suggested that the District 1 and 2 councilors hold a joint district meeting in early December to inform residents of this change and get input.
Councilor Ana Devlin Gauthier said District 5 residents would be happy to have a new fire station site closer to South Amherst.
In public comment, Planning Board Chair Doug Marshall cautioned about locating the DPW at Ruxton. “Even with the severely reduced program for the DPW, the existing site really is inadequate, but it turns out the Pulpit Hill site barely accommodated that existing program. So, it feels like for a facility that will be there probably for 50 years, spending $35 million on a project that has no capacity for expansion feels a little bit short-sighted.”
The DPW Building Committee’s next meeting is November 18 at 10 a.m.
