Housing Trust Recommends Accepting Monetary Payment in Lieu of Affordable Units in Dickinson Street Project

0
Housing Trust Recommends Accepting Monetary Payment in Lieu of Affordable Units in Dickinson Street Project

Architect's rendering of the proposed housing development at 24 Dickinson St. Photo: amherstma.gov

Report on the Meeting of the Amherst Municipal Affordable Housing Trust, Nov. 12, 2026

This meeting was held over Zoom and was recorded.

Present
Gaston de los Reyes (chair), Hejae Kim, Karla Rasche, Eason Zhou, and Paul Bockelman (Town Manager).  Staff: Greg Richane (Housing Coordinator)


Proposed Building on Dickinson Street Will Serve Amherst College

Barry Roberts plans to build a three-story building at 24 Dickinson Street that will be leased to Amherst College. He has requested a waiver of the two affordable units required by the Inclusionary Zoning Bylaw (Article 15.71) and proposes to contribute $1,990,400 to the Amherst Municipal Affordable Housing Trust (AMAHT) in lieu of providing the two units. 

This is the second project for which Roberts has asked for a waiver of the required affordable units. In 2024, the housing trust accepted a $1.2 million payment in lieu of four affordable units at 45-55 South Pleasant Street, which is now an Amherst College dorm. Subsequently, the town raised the required payment-in-lieu amount from four to five to eight times the area median income per unit. 

Attorney Tom Reidy of Bacon, Wilson LLC, representing Roberts, said that the building will have a daycare center for up to 70 children on the first floor and 19 apartments (one studio and one three-bedroom unit, with the rest being one- and two-bedroom units) for Amherst College faculty on the second and third floors. The daycare center will replace Woodside Children’s Center. 

The nearly $2 million payment is the maximum specified in the revised bylaw. Roberts is offering an amount that is eight times the area median income. Amherst College will have a 25-year lease that is renewable for another 25 years. 

Although AMAHT members were grateful that the developer offered the maximum compensatory payment and voted 5-0 to recommend that the Planning Board accept it, they advised the Planning Board to inquire about the property’s taxability if it transfers to Amherst College. 

Town Manager Paul Bockelman said that Amherst College is taxed for property not directly related to its educational mission. Bockelman, a member of AMAHT, wanted assurance that the property would remain on the town’s tax rolls, but Reidy was unsure how to prevent the college from taking it over in the future. He suggested including an agreement in the permit that would require Amherst College to pay PILOT (payment in lieu of taxes) funds to the town if it bought the property. Roberts currently owns 24 Dickinson Street. Amherst College owns 34 Dickinson Street. The house previously at 24 Dickinson has been moved to North Whitney Street, and the house at 34 is planned to be moved.

The Planning Board is responsible for granting the project permit and approving the waiver of the affordable units. 

AMAHT Chair Gaston de los Reyes said he asked for the “net present value” (value of future income compared to initial cost) of getting the waiver on the affordable units in the South Pleasant Street project and never received that information. “You didn’t even tell us you had a deal with Amherst College last time, so we didn’t have that kind of transparency,” he said. He requested that information for the current project.

Architect’s rendering of four views of the proposed housing development at 24 Dickinson Street. Photo: amherstma.gov

Housing Trust Gives $65K for Predevelopment Work on Year-Round Shelter

AMAHT voted unanimously to award $65,000 for predevelopment work for a year-round shelter to be built at 457 Main Street, the previous site of the VFW building. Assistant Planning Director Alexis Wheeler said the plans are to construct a building with 35 to 40 congregate shelter beds and 25 to 30 permanently supportive housing units with services for residents of both the apartments and the shelter. 

The town awarded the construction contract to Home City Development. The architect is Joy Squared. The funds requested would be used for geotechnical site exploration and to identify any concerning conditions at the site. This initial work is non-invasive.

Construction is scheduled to begin in early 2029.

Wayfinders Project at East Street School and Belchertown Road to Submit New Application

Housing Coordinator Greg Richane announced that the state Executive Office of Housing and Livable Communities (EOHLC) has invited the Wayfinders affordable housing project at the former East Street School and on Belchertown Road to submit another application. A previous application was denied. The project will be called Bluebird. 

Richane also reported that Craig’s Doors has been approved for 10 more beds in the shelter for the coming winter. Also, half of the 30 affordable homes at Amherst Community Homes have purchase-and-sale agreements. 

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

The Amherst Indy welcomes your comment on this article. Comments must be signed with your real, full name & contact information; and must be factual and civil. See the Indy comment policy for more information.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.