League Of Women Voters Calls For Transparent Police Chief Selection Process


Entrance to Amherst Police Department. Photo: Art Keene

Source: League of Women Voters Amherst

The League of Women voters Amherst issued the following statement on April 26, 2023, calling for a transparent process in selecting Amherst’s next police chief.

The process of hiring a new Police Chief for Amherst presents an important opportunity to build trust.  Transparency will be critical to developing community trust in the selection process, with active communications and public input at all stages.     

      We offer a few suggestions to encourage an open process that includes public engagement:

  • Directly involve the CSSJC in all phases of the process, including the selection process for a consultant.
  • Hold an open forum at the start, to explain publicly the steps in the selection process and to collect public comments.
  • Seek a pool of candidates who bring a broad range of experience, including experience and skill dealing with community conflict.
  • Include members of the public on the committee reviewing the candidates, reflecting the racial and ethnic composition of the community.
  • Create opportunities for the public to meet the candidates.

The LWVA and its Racial Justice Committee commend the Town for acting on the recommendations of the Community Safety Working Group to establish the CRESS program, the new DEI department, and the Community Safety and Social Justice Committee (CSSJC).  These vital changes, however, are only the beginning.  At this historic transition, it is crucial to create trust that our institutions are working and caring for everyone, and particularly for BIPOC communities and individuals.

The League of Women Voters of Amherst is a nonpartisan political organization that works to encourage informed and active participation in government. We support widespread and inclusive participation in local government and openness in the decision-making process.

The League supports a professional police force sensitive to the needs of all segments of the community and accessible to the public.

Spread the love

2 thoughts on “League Of Women Voters Calls For Transparent Police Chief Selection Process

  1. If the Amherst League of Women Voters is a nonpartisan political organization, it should behave like one. There is nothing “nonpartisan” about insisting that a nonelected group of individuals in town, the CSSJC, should have some greater say, perhaps even veto power, greater than other residents in town in the selection of a police chief. There’s an audacity about this that is breathtaking. The CSSJC has already had a lot to say about important choices in town government, without any clear boundaries and without ever having to face the voters. This is thoroughly undemocratic, with no resemblance to “consent of the governed”. It’s disappointing to see the LWV, which has a venerable history in Amherst and across the nation, making these sorts of demands, demands that elevate certain residents over others in the entire selection process. Is the CSSJC now a permanent shadow government embedded inside municipal government? And who decided that and when?

  2. The League of Women Voters is non-partisan, but it is not impartial. The League takes positions and advocates to make change, especially to support greater citizen involvement in local government. This includes advocating for people of all backgrounds who contribute their time and expertise on appointed town committees — some with enormous decision-making authority — all of whom are not elected, such as the Planning Board, the Zoning Board, and the Community Safety and Social Justice Committee. This comment was also signed by: Lydia de Faveri Spiegel, Andrea Battle, Renee Moss, Ash Hartwell, Meg Gage

Leave a Reply

The Amherst Indy welcomes your comment on this article. Comments must be signed with your real, full name & contact information; and must be factual and civil. See the Indy comment policy for more information.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.