solar in forest

Photo: Shutterstock

Ballot Question 6 seems sensible: Water is vital, and we should protect nature. But it will not address threats to the Commonwealth’s water. Instead, it will limit land vital for green energy, the most effective way to counter climate change. It would do this to secure more outdoor recreation for people in Massachusetts, who have twice the national average and the fastest-growing access to outdoor recreation in the country.

The threats to water in the Commonwealth are not a loss of wild land. The threats are industrial wastes, landfills, sewage, lead pipes and contaminated wells. These problems will not be solved by protecting forests. They must be solved by regulations on manufacturing, disposal, farming and upgrades to infrastructure. Saying Question 6 will protect water manipulates public anxiety in order to advance another agenda.

The $100 million per year raised by the proposal will have the effect of reducing potential space for solar by securing more forests for recreation. This is the disposition of The Mass Audubon Society (proposal’s principal sponsor), which has misleadingly targeted ground-mounted solar as a serious threat to the Commonwealth’s trees, in online media, If passed, we will fail to reduce our MA carbon footprint -twice the global average- and fail to reverse our immoral use of the world’s atmosphere as a free carbon dump. It’s hard to lose some woodlands but solar farms are ten times better at keeping carbon out of the atmosphere than forests. Moreover, we can not site nearly enough panels on infrastructure to meet our needs, even without data centers.

Yet, environmental groups gripe about 5,000 acres -only 0.07% of MA land- dedicated to solar while being silent about the destruction of 1,600,000 acres of tropical forests in Puerto Rico and Jamaica, alone -20.0% of their land. This destruction is aggravated by our carbon-strengthening hurricanes, and Question 6 will only make this worse. It will also help turn the hotter summers we now have in the Commonwealth into wildfire zones that could, ironically, destroy any new “protected” forests in the coming years. 

So cast a NO vote on Question 6 because nature is more than today’s trees. It is the entire atmosphere we share with everything, forever. 

Think globally, Act locally.

Nick Shaw

Nick Shaw is a resident of Amherst and a retired environmental science teacher at Amherst Regional High School
.

l

Spread the love

4 thoughts on “Letter: Vote No on Question 6”

  1. According to William E (Bill) Rees, a system scientist, ecologist, and developer of Ecological Footprint Analysis in the mid-90s, Climate Change is just one symptom of human overshoot. (Population and throughput) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_E._Rees

    His analysis shows that road building, huge machinery use in mining, transportation of ores, smelting and refining (includes the silicon), transportation at every step, manufacture of supportive infrastructure, assembly on site, maintenance, disassembly after ~1/4C, recycling what is possible (uses energy) disposal of non-recyclables in landfills…is dependent on fossil fuels. See from Grok:

    From front (sun side) to back:
    Tempered low-iron glass (front sheet, often ~3.2 mm thick): Provides mechanical protection, UV resistance, and high light transmission. This is the largest component by mass—commonly ~67–80%.
    Encapsulant (usually EVA—ethylene vinyl acetate—or POE—polyolefin elastomer, ~0.45–0.5 mm layers above and below the cells): Bonds the layers, provides electrical isolation, and acts as a moisture barrier.

    Solar cells: Thin wafers of crystalline silicon (~140 µm thick) doped with small amounts of boron (p-type) and/or phosphorus (n-type) to form the p-n junction. An anti-reflective coating (often silicon nitride, SiN) is applied. Silver paste forms the front-side grid lines (fingers/busbars) for collecting current; the rear often uses aluminum or silver contacts. Silicon accounts for only ~2.7–5% of panel mass but does the actual photovoltaic conversion.

    Interconnects: Tinned copper ribbon that links cells in series/parallel.

    Backsheet (or a second glass sheet in glass-glass modules): Multi-layer polymer (e.g., Tedlar/PVF, PET, or similar) for moisture barrier, insulation, and durability—or rear glass.
    Aluminum frame (anodized, typically AlMg3 alloy): Structural support and mounting interface (~8–13% by mass).

    Junction box: Plastic housing (e.g., PPO or PA) with bypass diodes and cables for DC output.

    The transfer of emissions from fossil fuels, hydro, nuclear…electricity generation (mostly coal and n.gas globally) to solar isn’t a huge win given the embedded energy in solar systems, and after ~25 years, the infrastructure must be replaced.

    Rees and many others claim that only a reversal in energy throughput in the human economy has any chance of reversing GHG emissions. The Growth God is not dead. Voluntary Simplicity is a tiny tail on the Bell Curve in our species. It is an exception which proves the rule. All known species follow this principle of bio-physics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum_power_principle

    Population growth will likely reverse this carbon Negative feedback and is the primary driver of the rapid decline in human fertility. See Hans Selye’s General Adaptation Syndrome. Peak fossil fuels and other resources will kick in as well. Human intentionality is unlikely to be the driver.

  2. Solar panels should be deployed exclusively on rooftops and over parking lots. When every one of these sites is producing energy, we can start spoiling open land with it.

  3. Local and major environmental organizations agree that solar arrays belong on rooftops and over parking lots, NOT in forests, which sequester carbon. Vote YES on Question 6.

Leave a Reply

The Amherst Indy welcomes your comment on this article. Comments must be signed with your real, full name & contact information; and must be factual and civil. See the Indy comment policy for more information.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.