Town’s Lawyers Say Library Trustees Can Withhold Information, but Reveal Trustees Are Considering Litigation Against a “Particular Party”
Photo: Blue Diamond Gallery. (CC BY-SA-3.0)
An Open Meeting Law violation complaint was filed on Oct. 26, 2026, by Amherst resident Jeff Lee against the Trustees of Jones Library Inc. for failing to disclose sufficient information before conducting Executive Sessions on October 15 and 22, 2026, “to discuss strategy with respect to litigation”. The Trustees again retreated into Executive Session on November 4 to discuss their response to the complaint and further indicated that they would authorize the town attorney to submit it. That response was sent on November 13 and, according to the Massachusetts Office of the Attorney General’s Division of Open Government, if the complainant is not satisfied, they have 90 days from the original complaint to appeal to the Attorney General for review, investigation, and enforcement of any required remedial actions.
Lauren Goldberg, a lawyer at KP Law, submitted a response to the complaint after advising the AG that her office serves as town attorney for Amherst and that KP Law’s response is “based on information provided to this office by the Town”. She acknowledged that “the Division of Open Government advises that when meeting in executive session to discuss litigation strategy under Purpose 3, the name of the case would generally be included on an agenda” but argued that “the Board did not identify the specific litigation, based on legitimate concerns regarding the confidentiality of its legal strategy and the potential consequences of prematurely disclosing its intentions”. She went on:
“The purpose of the discussion, although related to a matter about which the public may have been aware, was not, from the Board’s perspective, necessarily an “issue” about which the public was familiar. The Board intended to consider whether litigation could or should be initiated against a particular party, the appropriate timing of such litigation, if any, and the potential legal and practical consequences to the Board and the Town of bringing such litigation. In turn, the Board was also concerned that, even if it were to choose not to pursue litigation, public disclosure of its deliberations could expose the Town to unfavorable consequences under federal or state law.”
The response did not explain what the public may have known or what issue it might be familiar with. It also did not provide any insight into what unfavorable consequences under federal or state law they were seeking to avoid. Nevertheless, Goldberg argued that the trustees had demonstrated a “reasonable basis” for the claim that they had “tangible, legitimate concerns” that “publicly identifying the prospective litigation and the party against whom the Board was considering taking action” could “compromise the Board’s, or the Town’s, litigating position”.
Goldberg also did not indicate whether KP Law is involved in any way in the litigation the trustees are considering. It is also unclear why the town attorney for Amherst became involved in an OML complaint against a separate entity, the Trustees of Jones Library, Inc.
The Amherst Indy will continue to report on this story as it evolves.

Yes, why is the Attorney that represents the town involved in providing an explanation (defense) for the Trustees of the Jones library who are not town employees/ contractors. Including failing to pay the town monies as agreed upon, this is the second “violation ” by the Trustees. Public funds, attorneys representing a public entity, no transparency….business as usual.