ZBA Declines to Remove Owner-occupancy Requirement for Shays Street Duplex

0
ZBA Declines to Remove Owner-occupancy Requirement for Shays Street Duplex

The ZBA declined to remove an owner occupancy requirement for this house at 28 Shays Street. Photo: Google Maps

Report on the meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals, Nov. 12, 2026

The meeting was held on Zoom and recorded.

Present
Everald Henry (chair), David Ahlfeld, Sarah Morton, David Sloviter, and Craig Meadows.
Staff: Steve McCarthy (licensing coordinator).


At a continuation of a public hearing that began Sept. 24, the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) denied owner Michael Ben-Chaim’s request to remove the owner-occupancy requirement from a 2012 special permit that allowed him to build a second unit at 28 Shays St. A condition of the permit requires the property to be his principal residence. For the past two years, Ben-Chaim has spent most of his time in New York, though he visits Amherst occasionally and stays in the second unit.

Inspection Services cited Ben-Chaim in June for violating the conditions of the permit. In response, he applied to the ZBA to remove the owner-occupancy requirement. Neighbors have also complained repeatedly that the property disrupts the neighborhood, citing ongoing problems with trash, noise, and unleashed dogs.

The special permit states, “The owner must reside in one of the units, and the permit shall expire if the property is no longer the principal domicile of the owner.” Other conditions of the permit govern parking, lighting, and noise. Neighbors have complained that all of these condition have been violated.

Ben-Chaim and his attorney, John McLaughlin of Green, Miles, Lipton & Fitz-Gibbon LLP, said the current tenants, whom neighbors described as disruptive, have been evicted and are moving out. They said Pipeline Management will oversee the property and visit it every week, an arrangement “over and above the standard management contract.” McLaughlin said the 2012 special permit could be amended. Without an amendment, he said, the house would revert to a single-family structure and the second unit would sit vacant, which runs counter to town and state efforts to create more housing.

ZBA member Sarah Morton said she was concerned the management agreement would not address disruptive after-hours activity. McLaughlin said Ben-Chaim would be available by phone at all times, but neighbors said he did not respond when they complained about dogs barking and coming onto their property. Ben-Chaim said the lease prohibits pets other than service animals, and that this is part of the reason the current tenants are being evicted.

Board member David Ahlfeld suggested amending the special permit to require a resident manager, as the board has done with other duplexes. McLaughlin said a resident manager would duplicate Pipeline’s services and was not needed.

Board member David Sloviter asked why Ben-Chaim wanted the owner-occupancy requirement removed if, as he said, he is often in Amherst. Ben-Chaim replied that he is getting older and is thinking about the future, when he might want to sell the property or move away permanently.

Neighbors Describe Long-standing Problems

During public comment, Hilda Greenbaum said she was on the ZBA when it issued the 2012 special permit and that the property has had problems from the beginning. She said she does not think it fits in the neighborhood.

Greg Keochakian, who lives across the street from the property, said he has noticed a “slow and gradual erosion of the things that we expect. And I’m hearing that there’s more discussion about more changes that are going to continue to erode some of the things that we had hoped to enjoy. It sounds like Mr. Ben-Chaim eventually wants to leave the property, so it seems that this whole discussion might be a little premature.”

Adam Gurvich, a tenant next door residing in the only Frank Lloyd Wright house in Massachusetts (the Baird House) said problems with lights shining onto his property remain unresolved. He also said the owner’s friend, who lives in the rear apartment that Ben-Chaim claims to share when he is in town, has set up an encampment beside the house and is outside “from sun up past sundown with his dogs barking.” He said Ben-Chaim did not respond when he called to report a bonfire on the property.

Board Rejects Amendment 1-4

ZBA Chair Everald Henry suggested amending the special permit conditionally to include the new management company and management plan, with Ben-Chaim required to return to the board to show he is complying with stricter conditions. Henry acknowledged that “the complaints are credible. The abutters have described noise, lights, barking dogs at all hours, and trash in the yard.” He said the owner-occupancy requirement was meant to ensure that a responsible adult was on site, and that the condition has already failed. In his view, denying the request to remove it would not solve the property’s problems.

Ahlfeld said he was open to amending the permit and that adding strict conditions was the best way to protect the neighborhood. He said he did not think making the property a single-family dwelling would solve the problems.

Board members Craig Meadows and Sloviter said the special permit had already been violated during the two years Ben-Chaim has not lived there as his principal residence. Sloviter said Ben-Chaim has had ample opportunity to correct the problems with the tenants but has not done so. “There have been complaints throughout the years. They are consistent in describing the problems and the lack of remedy, and I believe that it is our responsibility to address what the neighborhood needs, so I am not comfortable with a probationary period,” he said.

Meadows agreed. He said the special permit should be revoked and the house rented as a single unit with no more than four residents. He added that enforcement is the town’s responsibility, not the ZBA’s.

The board rejected Henry’s motion to amend the special permit to remove the owner-occupancy requirement 1-4, with only Henry voting in favor. Ben-Chaim’s appeal of the citation charging that he violated the permit conditions is still pending and is expected to come before the ZBA soon.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

The Amherst Indy welcomes your comment on this article. Comments must be signed with your real, full name & contact information; and must be factual and civil. See the Indy comment policy for more information.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.