DPW, Public Safety, and School Reps Describe Cost Drivers to Finance Committee
Amherst’s Finance Committee spent three hours on Nov. 17 hearing from DPW, police, fire, CRESS, and school officials about what is driving their FY28 budgets, and none offered an easy place to cut. The schools’ finance director, Shannon Bernacchia, said that at a 2.75% increase, “we will have a deficit and we will have to make reductions.” Three residents spoke in public comment, two questioning a $200,000 payment for electricity at Amethyst Brook Elementary (designed as a net-zero school).
The committee unanimously recommended three year-end financial orders and continued consideration of the rest, including a new Educational Stabilization Fund, over to its Nov. 24 meeting.
The virtual meeting was recorded.
Who Was There?
Committee: Cathy Schoen (chair), Lynn Griesemer (town councilor, District 2), Jill Brevik (town councilor, District 1), Sam MacLeod (town councilor, District 5), Anna Devlin-Gauthier (town councilor District 5), and resident non-voting members Cathleen Mitchell, Jeffrey Robert, and Joe Jayne.
Staff: Paul Bockelman (town manager) and Sean Mangano (finance director).
Guests: Amy Rusiecki (assistant superintendent of public works), Ron Young (Captain, Amherst Police), Lindsay Stromgren (Amherst fire chief), Camille Theriaque (CRESS Director), Shannon Bernacchia (school finance director), and Athena O’Keeffe (clerk of Town Council).
An Earlier Look
Mangano called the format “a little bit of a new process,” a chance to hear department costs “earlier in the year before the guidelines are set,” which the committee normally does in May. He had sent department heads three questions: what drives costs, how current funding supports or constrains them, and how reductions would affect them.
Department of Public Works

Rusiecki’s department spans water, wastewater, highways, trees and grounds, electrical, vehicle maintenance, engineering and the transfer station. Her top drivers are electricity and gasoline, which also lifts asphalt prices. “You can’t plow a road if you don’t have gas in the vehicle,” she said. Mangano quantified it: about 26,000 gallons of heating oil, 19,000 of diesel, and 26,000 of gasoline in FY26, with fuel up roughly a dollar a gallon, “at least a 60 to $70,000 increase just in the DPW.”
Labor is the other driver. A new contract added steps to the top of the pay grid, and vacancies peaked at 11 of about 70 positions this summer; five remain. Last year’s expired contract hurt recruiting: “I basically at times was offering people FY25 salaries even though we were into FY26.” Departments have also been balancing on vacancy savings. “We got really creative to make our budgets work,” Rusiecki said.
Asked what cuts could look like, she said the town “can’t only take care of 90% of the roads.” Real savings would mean letting something lapse, such as opening one pool instead of two, skipping some Plum Brook field maintenance or lighting fewer street lights.
Police Department

Young cited 40 hours of state-mandated training, the cost of academy and field training for recruits, and contract-driven replacement and overtime costs. The department is authorized for 45 officers and has 41, down from just over 50 a decade ago. Six positions are open, three are recruits in the academy, and a new hire takes about a year to work alone. “We’re at a staffing minimum on most of our shifts,” Young said, and investigators have been moved to patrol. Asked where he could cut, Young said, “I don’t know exactly how much we could cut,” given about 22,000 calls a year, most of them 911.
That minimum shift staffing, a sergeant and three officers, means any absence triggers backfill and leads to forced overtime. “The forced overtime is costly to the town, and it’s also costly on our people,” Young said.
He described Monday’s threat at Amherst Regional High School; three officers and a sergeant responded, and state police, Amherst College and UMass police sent help until about 10 officers were on scene. National guidance of two to 2.5 officers per 1,000 residents would mean over 80 officers in Amherst, which he called “probably unlikely.” Town Manager Paul Bockelman added that the work does not end with the call: each arrest or major incident brings “a ton of paperwork” and follow-up.
Fire/EMS Department

Stromgren said the fire department delivers 95% of its service by vehicle, so “we can’t save any fuel costs,” and runs around the clock, so utility increases hit harder. Medical supplies, vehicle repairs, and training for new hires, which appear as overtime, are also rising. Oil changes once done in-house now go outside because crews lack the time to do them. The roughly $5.8 million department generates about $3.5 million in ambulance revenue, and EMS calls this fall have been “off the scale.”
With every position filled for the first time in years, he forecast a deficit, because it is vacancies “that have offset our over expenditures.” Firefighters also mow, shovel and clean stations because there is no custodial budget. The part-time call force has about eight active members against 24 authorized. On cuts, his answer was brief: “My short answer is we can’t.”
Meanwhile, a student force of about 30 runs a nightly engine company that Stromgren called a big return on investment. Injuries, mostly strains from lifting patients, are down from five or six firefighters out a year ago to one; the town bears workers’ compensation costs in full.
Community Responders for Equity, Safety & Service (CRESS)

Theriaque said the state grant behind much of CRESS’s work is ending, so the department will rely on the town budget after FY27. She wants 10 responders and an assistant director. In one month this fall, 17 of 32 well-being calls could have gone to CRESS; eight did.
“It’s an iterative process,” Bockelman said, adding, “It’s not like we’re taking a load off the police.” Cuts would mean scaling back programming and outreach and delaying training, Theriaque said. Bockelman warned that in any layoff “our most diverse employees” would be hit first. Councilor Jill Brevik praised a report laying out CRESS’s return on investment and its case for more staff.
Elementary and Regional Schools

Bernacchia said most contracts rise about 3%, the transportation contract about 8%, and health insurance could rise 10% to 11%, a figure that will not be known until February. “We just automatically start within a deficit,” she said. Out-of-district special education placements can exceed $150,000 per student, plus transportation costs, though state circuit breaker reimbursement offsets some. The district is four or five bus drivers short, and its contractor is combining routes “almost every single day.” Jeffrey Robert asked why special education spending now exceeds regular instruction at the elementary level. She had no data on the cause but said, “we are seeing more students with more needs and more students with higher needs.”
MacLeod asked whether staff cuts are likely. “We will have a deficit and we will have to make reductions,” she answered, though she would not say how many. Elementary figures were to be discussed by the School Committee that evening. She said she will review caseloads, class sizes, and service mix, and is pursuing energy grants and new bus routes, though she cannot yet cite savings. She hopes to present the regional budget in January because “I don’t like to cause panic.” She noted the district already leans on school choice funds, circuit breaker reimbursement, grants, and a food service revolving fund, and a new middle school roof should cut repair costs. Chair Cathy Schoen cautioned that some school costs sit elsewhere: charter and choice assessments and part of non-teacher pensions are in the town budget, so “the costs are bigger” than the school lines show.
Public Comment
Maria Kopiki, District 5, urged that “a lot more homework” is needed by the Finance Committee before approving a $200,000 electricity payment for the new Amethyst Brook’s Elementary School which is designed to be a net-zero building. Kopicki asked for contracts, bills, invoices, and schedules showing when the solar array, currently not online, was due to connect. She said town leaders should hold contractors accountable. “My hope is that the Finance Committee will lead the way starting today.”
Tony Cunningham, District 1, asked for a chart of reserve balances and urged reconsidering the 5% and 10% reserve policy for “putting excessive pressure on the school budgets.” She questioned paying short-term debt while capital stabilization holds cash, and added, “I strongly oppose the town paying for these” (electric bills).
Esther Azar, District 1 said CRESS has not been fully funded and cutting it before it can fulfill its mandate “would be a big loss for the community.” She praised the proposed education stabilization fund and asked the committee to rework budget guidelines “so that we’re not having equal percentages across all departments.”
Free Cash and the Votes
Mangano said certified free cash is $12.2 million, including about $3.8 million from FY26 operations, $2.5 million of it is investment income, plus a roughly $2 million timing adjustment for the Centennial water plant that reversed.
By roll call, all eight members present voted yes on three financial order motions:
Order 12A: move $263,700 from General Stabilization to Capital Stabilization, restoring the 10% target.
Order 12B: send $48,177 in cannabis tax revenue to the Reparations Stabilization Fund, raising it to $737,804 toward $2 million.
Order 12C: send $1,638,262 to Capital Stabilization for a future fire station. Mangano said the fund could pass $20 million by FY30 against a $25 million to $30 million cost. Jeffrey warned that “every year that we delay we’re actually expanding the deficit to build.” Mangano said contributions depend on investment income, which “could dry up very quickly” if rates fall.
The establishment of an educational stabilization fund which requires a two-thirds council vote was held for more work. A memo from Bockelman proposing that free cash be used to create the new fund explains that this “requires the reduction in request for roads by $1,000,000 (from $4,000,000 to $3,000,000)” and cuts the reserve for the new fire station by about $438,262. If the council does not adopt the fund, those sums go back to roads and Capital Stabilization. The roads and fire station reductions together equal the $1,438,262.
Discussion of the $200,000 for Amethyst Brook School electricity will wait until Special Capital Projects Coordinator Bob Peirent joins the next Finance Committee meeting on Nov. 24.
